Tuesday, October 02, 2007

"Whose war?"

Ben Smith:
This strikes me as a key passage of Obama's speech, a response to Hillary's claim that this is George Bush's war, and Mark Penn's meta-claim that Democrats ought to define it that way:

There are those who offer up easy answers. They will assert that Iraq is George Bush’s war, it’s all his fault. Or that Iraq was botched by the arrogance and incompetence of Donald Rumsfeld and Dick Cheney. Or that we would have gotten Iraq right if we went in with more troops, or if we had a different proconsul instead of Paul Bremer, or if only there were a stronger Iraqi Prime Minister.

These are the easy answers. And like most easy answers, they are partially true. But they don’t tell the whole truth, because they overlook a harder and more fundamental truth. The hard truth is that the war in Iraq is not about a catalog of many mistakes – it is about one big mistake. The war in Iraq should never have been fought.

Labels: ,


Post a Comment

<< Home